Feminist evaluation starts from the assumption that gender matters. Rather than merely measuring outcomes, it interrogates the extent to which an intervention contributes to social justice and gender equity, with particular attention to persons who are marginalised or at risk of marginalisation. For ARCO, feminist evaluation constitutes neither a methodological label nor a procedural framework, but rather an epistemological stance. Acknowledging that gender is consequential, that power relations permeate development processes, and that the production of knowledge is never neutral, entails designing evaluations capable of analysing inequalities through an intersectional lens, meaningfully engaging those directly affected, and yielding findings oriented towards social transformation.

Evaluation is not neutral: an apparently neutral approach risks obscuring structural dynamics and reproducing existing power asymmetries.

Feminist evaluation emerged in the 1990s and was first systematised theoretically in the early 2000s (see the contributions of Seigart, Brisolara and SenGupta, 2014). There is no single definition of feminist evaluation, just as there is no single definition of feminism. However, there are elements common to all approaches: the recognition that most societies are organised according to patriarchal norms and institutions and that gender cannot be analysed separately from other axes of inequality such as disability, ethnicity, sexual orientation and socio-economic status.

The application of a participatory feminist approach therefore makes it possible to assess the extent to which, regardless of the sector of intervention, a project:

  • has strengthened the empowerment of women and their organisations;
  • has produced changes at the micro level, for example in intra-family power balances;
  • has had an impact at the macro level, challenging patriarchal structural and political arrangements.

In the context of international cooperation, this orientation is intertwined with the debate on the decolonisation of evaluation and the importance of localised indicators that reflect local priorities, meanings and knowledge systems.

For ARCO, adopting a feminist approach to evaluation means integrating this perspective across all phases of the evaluative process:

  • In the evaluation design, through a participatory definition of key concepts — gender, inclusion, intersectionality, empowerment — as an initial operational step. Methodological considerations include, for instance, sex-matched interviews and targeted training for the data collection team, alongside the development of a detailed ethical protocol designed to ensure quality, consistency, and the safeguarding of participants’ wellbeing, particularly when sensitive subjects are addressed.
  • In the design and submission of the evaluation tools, by applying participatory methods and ensuring the meaningful involvement of stakeholders at every stage: from the definition of the evaluation design, to the construction and application of tools, through to the validation of findings. The aim, therefore, is not solely to extract information from those participating in evaluative activities; rather, evaluation seeks to enhance the empowerment of the beneficiaries involved. Alongside standard evaluative instruments, space is given to more accessible tools such as photo-voice, which enables participation in data collection even among those with limited literacy. The selection of indicators is not confined to identifying outputs, but seeks to surface processes and capabilities in accordance with the capabilities approach.
  • In the application of a feminist and inclusive lens to evaluative criteria, employing the OECD-DAC criteria (relevance, coherence, effectiveness, impact, efficiency, and sustainability) as a reference framework, whilst incorporating an analysis attentive to gender inequalities and other dimensions of exclusion.
  • In data analysis and the dissemination of the evaluation results, acknowledging the significance of reporting back to beneficiaries and the communities involved as a moment of accountability and further empowerment.

ARCO employs its own empowerment framework and attends carefully to different levels of analysis, whereby the micro level — encompassing women and family dynamics — is consistently situated within a macro framework, so as to foreground the structural nature of inequalities

The feminist approach
to the evaluation of projects

Feminist evaluation is, therefore, best understood as a lens to be applied across the whole evaluative practice, rather than as a predefined set of methods. Certain tools — such as outcome mapping, outcome harvesting, and Emancipatory Research — lend themselves particularly well to this orientation, as they facilitate participatory processes and give prominence to changes in behaviours, power relations, and the capacities of the actors involved. Nevertheless, what qualifies an evaluation as feminist is neither the method itself, nor the object of evaluation, but rather the attention given to structural asymmetries and the commitment to producing knowledge capable of challenging patriarchal systems and other intersectional forms of oppression.

To adopt such a perspective means situating every evaluative exercise within a broader vision of structural change, proceeding from the assumption that the production of evidence is never neutral, but always part of a wider contestation over meanings, priorities, and development trajectories. Evaluation thus becomes a space for collective learning and shared accountability, oriented not merely towards the measurement of outcomes, but towards the advancement of societies that are more just, more inclusive, and free from gender-based violence.

Leave a comment

This site is registered on wpml.org as a development site. Switch to a production site key to remove this banner.